CROA

VantageScore vs. FICO: What You Need to Know

Jeffrey S. Hyslip
Jeffrey S. Hyslip
April 16, 20242 min read

The Credit Score You Didn't Know You Had

For decades, FICO was the only name in town. But in 2006, the three major credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion) joined forces to create a competitor: VantageScore.

Today, VantageScore is used by billions of lenders, landlords, and financial institutions. Yet, many consumers are confused about how it differs from the classic FICO score. Understanding this difference is critical to mastering your financial defense.

The Breakdown: How It's Calculated

Unlike FICO, which can be secretive about its exact formula, VantageScore 3.0 and 4.0 are more transparent about what matters. The heaviest weighting goes to your track record:

VantageScore Weighting Factors

Payment History40%
Age & Type of Credit21%
Credit Utilization20%
Total Balances11%
Recent Credit5%
Available Credit3%

VantageScore vs. FICO: The Showdown

While both scores range from 300 to 850, they treat consumers differently. VantageScore is generally more "inclusive," meaning it can generate a score for people with less credit history (thin files) than FICO can.

FeatureFICO ScoreVantageScore
Minimum HistoryRequires 6 months of credit history to generate a score.Can generate a score with just 1 month of history.
Paid CollectionsOften still count against your score (older versions).Ignores paid collection accounts (VantageScore 3.0/4.0).
Hard InquiriesDeducts points for recent credit applications.Groups inquiries made within a 14-day window as one.

Why It Matters for Tenant Screening & Loans

If you are applying for an apartment or a personal loan, there is a high chance the landlord or lender is using VantageScore. Because it is friendlier to those with "thin" credit files, it has become a favorite for screening tenants and approving smaller loans.

Pro Tip: Don't panic if your FICO and VantageScore numbers are different. It is normal for them to vary by 20-40 points. Focus on the trends, not the exact number.
Jeffrey S. Hyslip
About the Author

Jeffrey S. Hyslip

Jeffrey S. Hyslip is the founding attorney of Hyslip Legal, where he focuses exclusively on consumer protection law. With over a decade of experience fighting debt collectors, credit bureaus, and financial institutions, he has helped thousands of clients recover damages and restore their peace of mind. He is admitted to practice in Ohio and multiple federal courts.

Read Full Bio →